Led Zeppelin – What Is and What Should Never Be: A Haunting Exploration of Desire and Regret
In the annals of rock history, Led Zeppelin stands as a titan. Their music, a potent blend of blues, rock, and folk, continues to resonate with listeners decades after its creation. Among their early gems, “What Is and What Should Never Be” stands out as a haunting and introspective ballad, a stark contrast to the band’s usual bombastic sound.
Released in 1969 on their seminal album Led Zeppelin II, “What Is and What Should Never Be” marked a turning point in the band’s development. While showcasing their signature heavy riffs and Jimmy Page’s soaring guitar work, the song also introduced a vulnerability not often explored in their earlier material. This vulnerability is particularly evident in vocalist Robert Plant’s poignant lyrics, which delve into themes of forbidden love and the pangs of regret.
The song’s narrative unfolds as a man wrestles with his desires for someone seemingly unattainable. The lyrics, co-written by Jimmy Page and Robert Plant, are veiled in ambiguity, leaving listeners to ponder the nature of the forbidden relationship. Plant’s evocative imagery paints a picture of longing and heartache, as heard in lines like:
“Her voice is soft as summer rain / And whispers of what might have been.”
The song’s musical arrangement masterfully complements the emotional weight of the lyrics. Jimmy Page’s acoustic guitar sets a melancholic tone, creating a stark contrast to the band’s trademark heavy sound. John Bonham’s subtle drumming and John Paul Jones’ melancholic bassline provide a foundation for Plant’s impassioned vocals. However, the song doesn’t shy away from showcasing Led Zeppelin’s power. The instrumental bridge explodes with Page’s characteristically distorted guitar solo, adding a layer of raw emotion before the song returns to its softer conclusion.
“What Is and What Should Never Be” became a fan favorite, a staple of the band’s early live performances. Its enduring popularity lies in its ability to capture the universal themes of longing, regret, and the complexities of human relationships. It’s a song that resonates with listeners of all ages, offering a glimpse into the emotional depth that lay beneath Led Zeppelin’s powerful rock exterior.
Video
Here are some additional details about the song:
- “What Is and What Should Never Be” was co-written by Jimmy Page and Robert Plant.
- It was released in 1969 on the album Led Zeppelin II.
- The song is considered a departure from Led Zeppelin’s usual hard rock sound, showcasing their versatility as musicians.